Projected losses from a serious California earthquake soar. What’s behind seismic inflation?
The expected annual cost from earthquake damage in California is climbing sharply amid an increase in property values and a better understanding of how soft soils could result in greater damage during shaking.
Support local news coverage and the people who report it by subscribing to the Napa Valley Register.
California is projected to lose an average of $9.6 billion a year from earthquake damage, the new estimates show. That’s a 157% increase from the last estimate, in 2017, when the price tag was $3.7 billion a year, according to a new report from the U.S. Geological Survey and the Federal Emergency Management Agency.
“In any given year a big earthquake strikes … you can easily anticipate a $100 billion loss,” USGS research structural engineer Kishor Jaiswal, the principal investigator for the report, told the Los Angeles Times.
People are also reading…
The totals underscore just how much the value of older buildings has soared in recent years, yet they remain vulnerable to major damage or collapse in the next big earthquake.
It is also a sober reminder of the seismic toll facing California. After the state’s other major earthquakes — in 1906 in San Francisco, 1933 in Long Beach, 1989 in the Bay Area and 1994 in Northridge — it took years, if not decades, for cities to recover, and massive costs had to be paid not only by governments and insurers but also individuals who were never made whole.
According to the new report, Los Angeles and Orange counties share the highest price tag of any metro area in the nation, with a combined projected average annual loss of $3.3 billion a year. In second place is the San Francisco-Oakland-Berkeley metro area, with a projected loss of $1.8 billion a year.
The seismic price tag for California is about 65% of the nation’s annual earthquake cost, which is $14.7 billion a year.
The projected annual average earthquake losses in other areas of California include $1.3 billion for Riverside and San Bernardino counties, $917 million for the San Jose-Sunnyvale-Santa Clara metro area, $285 million for San Diego County and $220 million for Ventura County.
Assuming the yearly earthquake loss projection remains the same, over the course of three decades, California is projected to lose $288 billion from earthquake damage. Such a figure is consistent with recent earthquake scenarios, such as a magnitude 7.8 earthquake on the southern San Andreas fault or a magnitude 7 earthquake on the Hayward fault.
Of that total, the five-county Southern California region — L.A., Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino and Ventura counties — would lose nearly $150 billion. And the nine-county Bay Area would lose roughly $90 billion.
“It’s a sobering reminder about why we need to prepare for those rare but large earthquakes, as just one major event can eclipse the costs of the more frequent but smaller ones,” USGS Director David Applegate said in a statement.
The authors of the report calculated an “annualized” earthquake loss to average out the cost of earthquake damage on a yearly basis.
It’s similar to how car insurers calculate the premium people pay yearly: People might be in a collision once every few years, but insurers calculate a yearly bill for drivers that takes into account the annual average projected cost of future collisions. How much the yearly car insurance premium will be can vary, depending on factors such as the driver’s age, accident history and the type of vehicle driven.
The magnitude 6.7 earthquake that hit Northridge in 1994 caused as much as $20 billion in damage and more than $40 billion in economic loss, “making it the costliest earthquake disaster in U.S. history,” according to the California Geological Survey.
And the damage from that earthquake, centered in the suburban San Fernando Valley, pales in comparison to the destruction that a major quake centered beneath older neighborhoods, such as in downtown L.A., would cause.
The 1994 earthquake’s magnitude was relatively moderate. By contrast, a magnitude 7.8 earthquake would produce 45 times more energy, and such a temblor hasn’t hit Southern California since 1857 and Northern California since 1906.
The world’s last magnitude 7.8 earthquake struck in February, resulting in strong shaking in Turkey and Syria. More than 50,000 people died.
A significant portion of California’s buildings constructed in the 20th century are vulnerable to earthquake damage or collapse. Retrofitting them now would leave cities far more resilient — keeping people alive, homes intact, and workplaces and neighborhoods functional.
The state’s rise in property values could enable some owners to use the equity they’ve accumulated to finance retrofits, experts say. A retrofit now can cost far less than repairing extensive damage after an earthquake, which could leave a building so wrecked it might need to be replaced.
Some cities in California have required property owners to retrofit certain types of vulnerable buildings. A Los Angeles law passed in 2015 requiring that apartment buildings with flimsy first stories — often used for carports — be strengthened has resulted in retrofits of more than 8,700 out of 12,400. That’s a completion rate of 70%. An analysis estimated that at least $1.3 billion was spent on those retrofits.
FEMA and state officials have worked to make grants available for retrofits. Homeowners in certain ZIP codes in Los Angeles, Pasadena, San Francisco, Oakland and Berkeley can apply for retrofit grants of up to $13,000 through the end of May to strengthen “soft-story homes,” where there’s a top-heavy living space built over a garage that is vulnerable to collapse in an earthquake.
“This study reinforces the nation’s need to be proactive about making communities safer from threats like earthquakes,” FEMA Deputy Administrator Erik Hooks said in a statement. “This includes adopting the latest seismic building codes and investing in earthquake resilience projects.”
But many other cities in California have not acted to require retrofits. And even in L.A., city officials have yet to address the potential seismic risk of older steel-frame high-rises built before the 1994 Northridge earthquake. The USGS has said that it is plausible that five steel-frame buildings in Southern California could collapse in a hypothetical magnitude 7.8 earthquake on the San Andreas fault, and 10 could be so damaged that they would be no longer safe to occupy.
Some cities remain far behind. Much of the Inland Empire, which covers Riverside and San Bernardino counties, still has many older brick buildings that are not retrofitted — among the highest-risk structures in an earthquake. They can collapse, not only killing the buildings’ occupants but also raining projectiles onto nearby sidewalks, parking lots and roads, with the remains of brick walls hurled with such force that they could crush cars and buses.
In the magnitude 6.9 Loma Prieta earthquake of 1989, a brick wall in San Francisco fell onto a parking lot, leaving cars crushed; five people died. And in a magnitude 6.3 quake that hit Christchurch, New Zealand, in 2011, falling bricks rained onto Red Bus No. 702, killing eight people, including the driver.
The number of people who need to be housed after a major earthquake could be enormous. The study estimated that a quake so large it had a 1-in-250 chance of occurring in any given year could result in more than 200,000 people needing short-term shelter in California. In an earthquake so large it had a 1-in-1,000 chance of occurring in any given year, more than 700,000 people would need short-term shelter.
The latest study also presents a more realistic picture of expected damage in places including L.A. and the Bay Area, where many buildings are on top of basins that amplify ground motions during an earthquake, Jaiswal said. Such shaking can result in a worse outcome for tall buildings that are atop basins compared with those built directly on bedrock.
“If you have a deep basin, with sediments overlaying on the hard rock, those ground motions get amplified,” Jaiswal said.
Compared to earlier models, the latest report factors in localized softer soil and basin conditions, which contributed to the increase in the projected damage cost for places such as L.A. and the Bay Area.
Other areas that saw an increase in earthquake hazard from the previous model include the Salt Lake City area, and much of the Big Island of Hawaii, Maui’s valley region and the southern coast of Oahu.
The Seattle area was estimated to have an annual earthquake loss of $781 million; the Portland, Oregon area, $403 million; the Salt Lake City area, $174 million; the Memphis, Tennessee area, $131 million; and the New York City region, $49 million.
The fact that earthquake risk exists in areas of the eastern U.S. may come as a surprise, but such quakes can happen. A magnitude 5.8 earthquake near Mineral, Virginia in 2011 caused $200 million to $300 million in damage, and necessitated $15 million in repairs to the Washington Monument.
Other damaging earthquakes in the eastern U.S. on record include one off of Cape Ann, Massachusetts in 1755, estimated to be magnitude 5.9, which resulted in damage to the Boston waterfront; an estimated magnitude 4.5 quake near Petersburg, Virginia in 1774, which shoved homes from their foundations and was felt by future President Thomas Jefferson; and an estimated magnitude 7 quake near Charleston, South Carolina in 1886 that killed 60 people, according to the USGS.
In the early 19th century, there were three large earthquakes in the New Madrid seismic zone, around the area along the Mississippi River where Tennessee, Kentucky, Illinois, Missouri and Arkansas meet. The largest earthquakes were a magnitude 7.5 in December 1811, a magnitude 7.3 in January 1812 and a magnitude 7.5 in February 1812.
“Earthquakes are a national problem,” the USGS said in a statement.
New York City has a low probability of a damaging earthquake, but one that occurs could still cause significant damage because of the city’s density and the age of its buildings, according to the city’s emergency management agency. One big risk for New York City is a large number of older brick buildings that have not been retrofitted.
In early October, a group of volunteers from Napa County Landmarks gathered at the Napa’s downtown historic post office. Their goal: rewrap the huge lanterns that flank the post office entrances. The post office was heavily damaged in the 2014 earthquake and has since been sold for development.
Throwback Thursday: Photos from the 2014 Napa earthquake
Fire damage after earthquake in Napa
Four homes were destroyed by fire after the quake and up to eight more were damaged at the Napa Valley Mobile Home Park, according to the Napa Fire Department. No injuries were reported.
Napa Earthquake
This building, located at Second and Brown streets, sustained major damage in Napa’s 6.0 earthquake. California is predicted to have a much stronger quake in coming decades.
Napa Earthquake
Browns Valley Market employees clean up the disaster left by the 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. on Sunday morning, August 24, 2014.
Napa Earthquake
Larry Giovannoni, owner of Browns Valley Market in Napa, pauses while cleaning up the disaster left by the earthquake. Giovannoni estimates that their losses will be over $1 million.
Napa Earthquake
Skateboarders use the buckled pavement of Meadowood Court as ramps for performing stunts after last August’s earthquake.
Napa Earthquake
While waiting for inspectors, Vintner’s Collective manager Garret Murphy stands outside the historic Main Street building whose facade was badly damaged in the Aug. 24 earthquake.
Napa Earthquake
Nicholas George of Carneros cranes his head down into a deep fissure in front of his house on Old Sonoma Road on the day of the South Napa earthquake Scientists used more sophisticated tools for measuring the quake.
Napa Earthquake
Two men walk past an earthquake-damaged home on First Street on Monday morning. Residents throughout the valley spent Monday assessing the damage and cleaning up from the 6.0 earthquake that struck Sunday.
Napa Earthquake
Damage is visible to the facade of the Napa post office on Second Street on Sunday morning following the quake. Repairs have not yet begun on the downtown building.
Napa Earthquake
The damaged facade at Alexandria Square at Brown and Second streets became an iconic image of Napa’s earthquake.
Napa Earthquake
A number of glass panes were broken at the downtown Napa Post Office following a 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Sunday, causing major damage to a number of downtown buildings.
Napa Earthquake
One of the many cracks that developed following Sunday mornings earthquake is seen on Old Sonoma Road on Monday morning. City and county crews were patching roads throughout the valley.
Napa Earthquake
The Historic Courthouse was red-tagged after a section of building fell off during Sunday’s 6.0 earthquake. Repairs will be expensive and take a year or more, officials say.
Napa Earthquake
Buckled and cracked asphalt, like seen here on Craigie Court, is a common sight throughout Napa following the 6.0 magnitude earthquake that struck on Sunday, Aug. 24 at 3:20 a.m.
Napa Earthquake
Jim Nichols of South Dakota disposes of debris at Browns Valley Elementary School on Monday morning following the 6.0 magnitude earthquake that struck Napa on Sunday morning. He was visiting his mother who lives in Napa when the quake struck and was cleaning up at her home. There are a number of locations where local residents can get rid of debris from the quake.
Napa quake debris
A mountain of earthquake debris — damaged dishes, furnishings and treasured possessions — is piled up in front of the Education Center at Jefferson Street and Lincoln Avenue Tuesday afternoon in Napa Valley. With schools reopening Wednesday, Napa Valley Unified School District is asking the community to cease using the Ed Center site. Debris boxes are available at a half-dozen city parks.
Napa Earthquake
Dennis Fagent, right, of ZFA Structural Engineers, and local architect and consultant Stephen Cuddy assess the damage done to the historic Vintner’s Collective building by Sunday’s 6.0 earthquake. The building was red tagged on Tuesday, but inspectors on Wednesday found that the inside of the building was intact, concluding that the repair needed was largely on the outside veneer.
Napa Earthquake
Structural damage to the Napa Square building has forced the closure of some neighboring buildings after Sunday’s 6.0 earthquake.
Napa Earthquake
Napa’s Chief Buidling Official Dan Kavarian tapes a red tag Thursday morning to the door of the recently opened Velo Pizzeria on Main Street. Though the restaurant was recently seismically retrofitted, it abuts a masonry building on Brown Street that poses a safety threat to adjacent structures, according to the city. The Brown Street building, which has also been red-tagged, is owned by Brian Silver, a Napa attorney.
who has historically refused to bring his buildings up to earthquake codes.
Napa Earthquake
Residents of the Charter Oaks Apartments on Browns Valley Road are seen near one of the carports that collapsed following a 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Sunday.
Napa Earthquake
This home at Vallejo and Yajome streets was knocked off its foundation following the 6.0 earthquake August earthquake.
Napa Earthquake
The sidewalk buckled where a crack went across Twin Oaks Drive and through the home of Tim and Ann Whitlock, knocking the two story home 5 inches off its foundation.
Napa Earthquake
A brick chimney on a home on Hermosa Drive lies in shambles after last August’s earthquake.
Napa Earthquake
A broken water pipe gushes a stream of water over a deep crack in the pavement along White Cliff Circle after a 6.0 earthquake struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. on Sunday morning, August 24, 2014.
Napa Earthquake
Napa firefighters spray down one of four homes at the Napa Valley Mobile Park destroyed by fire after a 6.0 earthquake struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Aug. 24. The fire department believes the fire was caused by a ruptured gas line.
Napa Earthquake
Falling debris damaged this car at Third and Brown streets following a magnitude 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Sunday.
Napa Earthquake
The Sam Kee Laundry building, which currently houses The Vintner’s Collective, shows damage from the 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Sunday.
Napa Earthquake
Napa firefighters subdue the last flames of a fire that destroyed 4 homes at the Napa Valley Mobile Park after a 6.0 earthquake struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Sunday morning, August 24, 2014. The fire department believes the fire was caused by a ruptured gas line.
Napa Earthquake
Quake caused major damage to the tasting room and barrel storage building at Trefethen Family Vineyards. This was originally the Eshcol Winery building, built in 1886, and is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
Napa Earthquake
One of the glass panels on the 9/11 Memorial in downtown Napa shattered following a 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. Sunday. A number of downtown buildings sustained major damage.
Napa Earthquake
Merchandise is tossed inside of Shackford’s Kitchen Store following a 6.0 earthquake which struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. causing major damage to a number of downtown buildings.
Napa Earthquake
This fountain in the Christian Brothers Courtyard at Justin-Siena High School was one of the casualties of Sunday morning’s 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa.
Napa Earthquake
A 6.0 earthquake struck Napa at 3:20 a.m. last Sunday. This photo was taken inside the Register newsroom.
Napa Earthquake
People stop to survey the damage to Quent Cordair Fine Art Gallery in downtown Napa following a 6.0 earthquake that struck Napa at 3:20 a.m.
Be the first to know
Get local news delivered to your inbox!
