By Chris Matthews and Madeleine Ross

23:24 20 Feb 2023, updated 00:19 21 Feb 2023

SNP frontrunner Kate Forbes called trans double rapist Isla Bryson ‘a man’ as she revealed she wouldn’t have voted for gay marriage a decade ago. 

The lead candidate for First Minister, the 32-year-old politician has been vocal about her concerns about the Scottish government’s controversial gender self-ID laws.  

Ms Forbes said: ‘No rapist can be a woman. Isla Bryson is a man,’ in an interview yesterday as she signalled that she wouldn’t continue legal action against the Westminster veto of the Scottish gender self-ID law. 

Questions of gender identity have haunted the final weeks of Nicola Sturgeon’s leadership as she repeatedly stumbled over questions about the double rapist’s sex. 

The finance secretary, 32, who is known to hold socially conservative views, also said in an interview that she would not have backed the legislation to make gay marriage legal but would have ‘respected and defended the democratic choice that was made’. 

SNP lead candidate Kate Forbes (pictured) said she would have voted against gay marriage in Scotland at the time it was made legal almost a decade ago Isla Bryson – formerly known as Andrew Graham – pictured outside court in Glasgow in January. Nicola Sturgeon has dodged questions about the convicted rapist’s gender identity

The Telegraph reported that the frontrunner said the gender legislation was ‘not a priority right now’ for Scotland, distancing herself from First Minister Nicola Sturgeon. 

‘I would be strongly minded not to proceed with that court challenge [against Westminster], subject to legal advice and so on. 

Read more: How outgoing leader’s ruthless ambition brought Scotland to the brink of independence before a series of scandals

‘I would much rather engage in discussion with the UK Government about the amendments that need to be made than proceed with the challenge.’

Ms Forbes previously said she would not have voted for the Scottish Government’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill in its current form. 

As she was on maternity leave, she did not participate in the final vote before the new year, but has been clear on her opposition since 2019.

She was one of 15 SNP politicians who publicly called on her party to delay the controversial proposals which make it easier for transgender people to self-identify as their chosen gender. 

She said: ‘My concerns about self-ID have been well documented and I would have continued to have those concerns about self-ID. 

‘It’s very difficult to talk hypothetically when it comes to a Bill but I think I would have struggled to support that self-ID element of the Gender Recognition Act.’ 

However, if she had voted against it, she would have been required to leave her position as Finance Secretary.

The comments come as Ms Forbes yesterday made clear her stance on gay marriage, as her religion and socially conservative views cause concern with some SNP voters. 

Equal marriage was made legal in Scotland in 2014 with an overwhelming majority of 105 votes to 18, while Ms Forbes was not elected to Holyrood until the 2016 election. 

Nicola Sturgeon dropped the bombshell that she is quitting last week, after a torrid spell where the SNP slid into chaos over its abortive bid to loosen gender identity rules and dwindling support for independence Humza Yousaf, 37, (pictured) is the Scottish Government’s health secretary, who became Scotland’s first Muslim Cabinet minister in 2018, when he was appointed justice secretary

Who is Humza Yousaf? 

Humza Yousaf, 37, is the Scottish Government’s health secretary, who became Scotland’s first Muslim Cabinet minister in 2018, when he was appointed justice secretary.

He has been MSP for Glasgow Pollok since 2016, having previously been elected to the Scottish Parliament as an additional member for the Glasgow region in 2011 at the age of just 26.

Despite being tipped as a possible replacement for Ms Sturgeon as First Minister, Mr Yousaf’s chances could be harmed by the current health crisis in Scotland.

He has come under particular pressure over long waiting times for ambulances and emergency care.

Mr Yousaf has a daughter and a stepchild with his second wife Nadia El-Nakla. 

Talking to The Scotsman, Ms Forbes, who has been on maternity leave and away from frontline politics since early summer last year, said she would not have supported equal marriage as a ‘matter of conscience’ if she had been a member of parliament at the time.

She cited the example of Angela Merkel as a leader who voted on the matter ‘with her conscience’.

She said: ‘I would have voted, as a matter of conscience, along the lines of mainstream teaching in most major religions that marriage is between a man and a woman. 

‘But I would have respected and defended the democratic choice that was made. 

‘It is a legal right now and I am a servant of democracy, I am not a dictator.’ 

After giving her views on gay marriage, the Scottish Health Secretary and SNP leadership candidate Humza Yousaf, 37, said in an interview that he would not legislate on the basis of his faith. 

Speaking on Tonight with Andrew Marr on LBC on Monday, Mr Yousaf said: ‘I’m a supporter of equal marriage. 

‘Let me get to the crux of the issue that you’re asking me. I’m a Muslim. I’m somebody who’s proud of my faith. 

‘I’ll be fasting during Ramadan in a few weeks’ time. 

‘But what I don’t do is, I don’t use my faith as a basis of legislation. 

‘What I do as a representative, as a leader, as a Member of the Scottish Parliament is my job is to bring forward policy and pursue it in the best interest of the country.’

Ms Forbes also condemned the ‘illiberal discourse’ around her faith and how her religious views could impact her decisions as First Minister. 

She is a member of the Free Church of Scotland and had previously said her faith did not impact her ability to serve as an MSP. 

Scottish finance secretary Kate Forbes swiped at the need to ‘widen’ the SNP’s appeal as she confirmed she is a candidate

She said: ‘It is quite an illiberal discourse. 

‘Because if we get into the territory of suggesting that anyone who holds public office is to be barred to people of faith, then it sends a very bad signal to the countless people of faith and no faith in Scotland today.’ 

Earlier, Ms Forbes committed to ensuring women are free from harassment and fear around abortion clinics following a plea from campaigners. 

She said women should not ‘be subjected to fear and harassment’ when attending clinics across the country. 

It comes as campaigners Back Off Scotland wrote to Ms Forbes – and her opponents in the leadership race Mr Yousaf and Ash Regan – to ask for support in implementing 150-metre safe access zones around hospitals administering abortions. 

She said: ‘I would say that I certainly don’t think that women going for an abortion should be subjected to fear and harassment. 

‘And so, I’d be willing to work with Gillian Mackay who is introducing the Bill.’

Who is SNP leadership contender Kate Forbes?

Kate Forbes is a leading member of Ms Sturgeon’s administration who is being tipped as the favourite to replace her.

The fluent Gaelic speaker became the Scottish government’s finance secretary in February 2020, the first woman to hold the post.

Kate Forbes married Alasdair MacLennan – a widower chimney sweep 10 years her senior – in July 2021.

Her husband, known as Ali, had three daughters – Rachael, Rebekah and Zara – with his Indian first wife Priya. She died in 2014, aged just 38.

Ms Forbes, 32, went on maternity leave last July – the first ever serving Scottish Cabinet secretary to do so – and gave birth to her daughter Naomi in August.

The daughter of missionaries, Ms Forbes spent much of her childhood in India.

She is a member of the Free Church of Scotland, sometimes known as the ‘Wee Frees’, which is opposed to gay marriage and believes there are few circumstances in which abortion is justified.

Ms Sturgeon’s government was accused of rushing through its controversial gender identity reforms before Christmas, while Ms Forbes remained on maternity leave, in order to prevent a potential revolt by the 32-year-old. 

The post SNP frontrunner Kate Forbes distances herself from Sturgeon by calling trans Isla Bryson a ‘MAN, appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.

By James Tapsfield, Political Editor For Mailonline

09:10 21 Feb 2023, updated 11:39 21 Feb 2023

SNP hopeful Kate Forbes today apologised for causing ‘pain or hurt’ by saying she would not have voted for gay marriage. 

The Scottish Finance Minister asked for ‘forgiveness’ as she desperately tries to save her bid to succeed Nicola Sturgeon.

Ms Forbes had been regarded as the front runner – but appears to have crashed within hours of formally declaring her intentions, with allies admitting she has ‘f***ed it up’. 

The meltdown leaves Health Secretary Humza Yousaf as the favourite to take over from Ms Sturgeon. 

Ms Forbes, a member of the Free Church of Scotland who cut short maternity leave to join the contest, faced a backlash after insisting that she views marriage as between a man and a woman.

The 32-year-old said she would have voted against same-sex marriage if she had been an MSP at the time, but stressed she would defend people’s rights under the law as it stands. 

A series of MSPs announced they were dropping their support afterwards, along with Westminster MP Drew Hendry. But in a round of interviews this morning, Ms Forbes denied her campaign was effectively over, and said she had not intended to offend anyone.

‘I regret enormously the pain or hurt that has been caused because that was neither my intention, and I would seek forgiveness if that is how it’s come across,’ she told Times Radio.

‘I regret enormously the pain or hurt that has been caused because that was neither my intention, and I would seek forgiveness if that is how it’s come across.’

Ms Forbes added that she defends the rights of LGBT+ people to live ‘free of harassment, fear and prejudice’.

However, on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme Ms Forbes reiterated that she would have opposed same-sex marriage. She compared her position to that of Angela Merkel, who agreed to a vote on the issue, opposed the change, but then implemented the will of the German Parliament. 

SNP lead candidate Kate Forbes (pictured yesterday) said she would have voted against gay marriage in Scotland at the time it was made legal almost a decade ago The meltdown leaves Health Secretary Humza Yousaf as the favourite to take over from Ms Sturgeon

Challenged on the BBC that her campaign was all-but finished, Ms Forbes said: ‘Absolutely not. We have a large party membership, most of whom are not on Twitter.

‘I understand people have very strong views on these matters. I think the public are longing for politicians to answer straight questions with straight answers and that’s certainly what I’ve tried to do in the media yesterday. That doesn’t necessarily allow for much nuance.

‘My position on these matters is that I will defend to the hilt everybody’s rights in a pluralistic and tolerant society, to live and to love free of harassment and fear.’

Equal marriage was made legal in Scotland in 2014 with an overwhelming majority of 105 votes to 18, while Ms Forbes was not elected to Holyrood until the 2016 election. 

Ms Forbes previously said she would not have voted for the Scottish Government’s Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill in its current form. 

As she was on maternity leave, she did not participate in the final vote before the new year, but has been clear on her opposition since 2019.

She was one of 15 SNP politicians who publicly called on her party to delay the controversial proposals which make it easier for transgender people to self-identify as their chosen gender. 

She said: ‘My concerns about self-ID have been well documented and I would have continued to have those concerns about self-ID. 

Read more: How outgoing leader’s ruthless ambition brought Scotland to the brink of independence before a series of scandals

‘It’s very difficult to talk hypothetically when it comes to a Bill but I think I would have struggled to support that self-ID element of the Gender Recognition Act.’ 

However, if she had voted against it, she would have been required to leave her position as Finance Secretary.

In another controversial intervention, Ms Forbes said the convicted transgender rapist who was initially placed in a female jail ‘is a man’.

Ms Sturgeon previously dodged questions over whether Isla Bryson, formerly known as Adam Graham, is a woman after the 31-year-old was found guilty of two sex attacks.

But speaking to the Daily Telegraph, Mrs Forbes said unequivocally that ‘no rapist can be a woman’ and that ‘Isla Bryson is a man’.

Mrs Forbes also accused her opponents of attacking her over her Christian beliefs ‘rather than competence, experience or vision’.

She said: ‘We need to be very careful that we are not saying in Scotland that you cannot hold public office, even the highest public office, if you are a member of a particular faith.

‘Or, you can hold public office, but you actually need to strip your faith out. That seems to me a very illiberal approach.

She added: ‘My approach is I’ve been open about faith, the influence of faith in my life.

‘But we appear to be able to have a Hindu in Number 10, is it beyond the pale to think we might have a Christian in Bute House?’

‘I would much rather engage in discussion with the UK Government about the amendments that need to be made than proceed with the challenge.’

Nicola Sturgeon dropped the bombshell that she is quitting last week, after a torrid spell where the SNP slid into chaos over its abortive bid to loosen gender identity rules and dwindling support for independence Isla Bryson – formerly known as Andrew Graham – pictured outside court in Glasgow in January

Who is Humza Yousaf? 

Humza Yousaf, 37, is the Scottish Government’s health secretary, who became Scotland’s first Muslim Cabinet minister in 2018, when he was appointed justice secretary.

He has been MSP for Glasgow Pollok since 2016, having previously been elected to the Scottish Parliament as an additional member for the Glasgow region in 2011 at the age of just 26.

Despite being tipped as a possible replacement for Ms Sturgeon as First Minister, Mr Yousaf’s chances could be harmed by the current health crisis in Scotland.

He has come under particular pressure over long waiting times for ambulances and emergency care.

Mr Yousaf has a daughter and a stepchild with his second wife Nadia El-Nakla. 

Talking to The Scotsman, Ms Forbes, who has been on maternity leave and away from frontline politics since early summer last year, said she would not have supported equal marriage as a ‘matter of conscience’ if she had been a member of parliament at the time.

She cited the example of Angela Merkel as a leader who voted on the matter ‘with her conscience’.

She said: ‘I would have voted, as a matter of conscience, along the lines of mainstream teaching in most major religions that marriage is between a man and a woman. 

‘But I would have respected and defended the democratic choice that was made. 

‘It is a legal right now and I am a servant of democracy, I am not a dictator.’ 

Ms Forbes also condemned the ‘illiberal discourse’ around her faith and how her religious views could impact her decisions as First Minister. 

She is a member of the Free Church of Scotland and had previously said her faith did not impact her ability to serve as an MSP. 

Mr Yousaf said he will ‘always fight for the equal rights of others’.

Asked what he thought of what Ms Forbes had to say on same sex marriage, Mr Yousaf told BBC Radio Scotland’s Good Morning Scotland programme: ‘It’s for her to defend her views, I’ve made my views very clear.

‘I think my track record on equality issues speaks loud and clear.

‘I’m a minority in this country, I have been my entire life and my rights don’t exist in some kind of vacuum, my rights are interdependent on other people’s rights and therefore I believe very firmly, in fact with every fibre in my being, that your equality is my equality, therefore I’ll always fight for the equal rights of others regardless of who they are.’

Scottish finance secretary Kate Forbes swiped at the need to ‘widen’ the SNP’s appeal as she confirmed she is a candidate

Who is SNP leadership contender Kate Forbes?

Kate Forbes is a leading member of Ms Sturgeon’s administration who is being tipped as the favourite to replace her.

The fluent Gaelic speaker became the Scottish government’s finance secretary in February 2020, the first woman to hold the post.

Kate Forbes married Alasdair MacLennan – a widower chimney sweep 10 years her senior – in July 2021.

Her husband, known as Ali, had three daughters – Rachael, Rebekah and Zara – with his Indian first wife Priya. She died in 2014, aged just 38.

Ms Forbes, 32, went on maternity leave last July – the first ever serving Scottish Cabinet secretary to do so – and gave birth to her daughter Naomi in August.

The daughter of missionaries, Ms Forbes spent much of her childhood in India.

She is a member of the Free Church of Scotland, sometimes known as the ‘Wee Frees’, which is opposed to gay marriage and believes there are few circumstances in which abortion is justified.

Ms Sturgeon’s government was accused of rushing through its controversial gender identity reforms before Christmas, while Ms Forbes remained on maternity leave, in order to prevent a potential revolt by the 32-year-old. 

The post SNP hopeful Kate Forbes struggles to save lots of bid to succeed Nicola Sturgeon appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.

By James Tapsfield, Political Editor at Mailonline

15:52 20 Feb 2023, updated 16:23 20 Feb 2023

• Race is to be succeeded by Nicola Sturgeon as head of the SNP and first minister
• Kate Forbes, who has long been talked about as a potential successor, announced today

SNP leadership hopefuls today plotted Nicola Sturgeon’s legacy as the battle to find her successor intensified.

Kate Forbes has cut her maternity leave to become the third confirmed candidate and suggested she would give up revising Ms Sturgeon’s gender identity.

The Scottish Finance Minister – seen by many as a front runner despite concerns about her links to a church opposed to abortion and gay marriage – lamented that the SNP needed a “broader” appeal and someone with a “fresh face”.

Meanwhile, Health Secretary Humza Yousaf made it clear that he has serious doubts about Ms Sturgeon’s plan to turn the next general election into a “de facto” referendum on independence.

The other declared contender, Ash Regan, had previously resigned from the Scottish Government to vote against its failed bid to relax trans rules.

Constitutional Secretary Angus Robertson said this morning that he would not run for the party’s top post.

Kate Forbes (pictured in Glasgow today) has cut her maternity leave to become the third confirmed candidate in a ‘de facto’ referendum on independence Ash Regan (pictured), who previously resigned from the Scottish Government so she could vote against her failed attempt to relax gender identity rules Ms Sturgeon (pictured on a visit to Midlothian today) dropped the bombshell that she is Scottish Finance Minister Kate Forbes announced last week after a hot spell in which the SNP descended into chaos over her failed attempt to relax gender identity rules and dwindling support for independence, denounced the need to “broaden” the SNP’s appeal when she confirmed she is a candidate

Ms Sturgeon dropped the bombshell she was dropping last week after a heated spell that saw the SNP thrown into chaos over its failed attempt to relax gender identity rules and dwindling support for independence.

Visiting the Roslin Institute in Midlothian today, minutes before Ms Forbes’ statement, she expressed “tremendous confidence that the SNP will select someone with ability”.

“It’s clear that there’s a spectrum of talent on display there.”

Speaking to the BBC this afternoon, Ms Forbes made a mark on the gender issue. “I understand the principle here that the UK Government should not repeal Scottish legislation,” she said.

“It’s an important principle that I stand by.

“But I am considering it, seeking legal advice and acknowledging that this is not a priority for the people of Scotland right now who are focused on other things.”

In a video previously posted to social media – with footage of the stunning Scottish countryside – a tartan-clad woman gave Forbes a nod to the apparently stalled Separatist campaign north of the border.

She warned that nationalists risked “being frustrated on the road to self-determination” and said she had the “vision, experience and competence to inspire voters across Scotland”.

Who is the contender for the SNP leadership, Kate Forbes?

Kate Forbes is a senior member of Ms Sturgeon’s administration, who is being tipped as the favorite to replace her.

The fluent Gaelic speaker became Finance Minister in the Scottish Government in February 2020, the first woman to hold the post.

Kate Forbes married Alasdair MacLennan – a widowed chimney sweep ten years her senior – in July 2021.

Their wedding was streamed online because Covid restrictions limited the number of people who could attend.

Her husband, known as Ali, had three daughters – Rachael, Rebekah and Zara – with his Indian first wife Priya. She died in 2014 at the age of just 38.

Ms Forbes, 32, went on maternity leave last July – the first ever acting Scottish Cabinet Secretary – and gave birth to their daughter Naomi in August.

It was previously believed that Ms Forbes harbored no leadership ambitions, although she has been touted as a future SNP leader since entering the Scottish Parliament as MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch in 2016.

The daughter of missionaries, Mrs. Forbes spent much of her childhood in India.

She is a member of the Free Church of Scotland, sometimes known as the ‘Wee Frees’, which opposes gay marriage and believes there are few circumstances in which an abortion is justified.

Ms Forbes has previously said she was “guilty” of “tiptoeing around” her Christian faith in interviews.

Ms Sturgeon’s government has been accused of rushing through its controversial gender identity reforms ahead of Christmas while Ms Forbes stayed on maternity leave to prevent a possible revolt by the 32-year-old.

“We urgently need to unleash the full talent of the SNP, the broader yes movement and the country as a whole,” she said.

Ms Forbes was hot-tipped despite concerns her ties to an anti-gay marriage and anti-abortion evangelical church could be harmful.

Appearing in the video against a backdrop of the Scottish countryside and with a tartan scarf around her neck, Ms Forbes said: “Friends in the SNP, our nation and our movement are at an important crossroads. The decisions we make over the next few weeks will have a profound impact on our future and the future of our children.

“I cannot sit back and watch as our nation is thwarted on the road to self-determination. Our small independent neighbors are enjoying more prosperous, fairer and greener societies, and so should we.

“We urgently need to unleash the full talent of the SNP, the broader yes movement and the country as a whole.

“We must elect strong, competent leadership to ensure independence, the leadership that I can offer.

“I think we need someone who can unite our party and our movement. I am a unifier, I will reach out and listen to make each member feel valued and empowered to contribute.

“This is also important if we want to convince others of the merits of independence. But now we also need someone who has our economy and our finances under control.

“In the midst of a cost of living crisis and the need to plan for independence, my years of managing the household and economy of Scotland have given me the experience we need to do just that.

“More than anything, we need a leader who is bold, courageous and energetic, with fresh faces and ready for new challenges.

“Someone who will inspire your confidence as an SNP member and inspire the people of Scotland to vote for a better future

“I am that leader and I want to lead our party to better days with integrity and commitment for the sake of your children and mine.”

Mr Yousaf and former community security minister Ms Regan clashed over three major policy issues – independence, gender reform and road building – yesterday as they confirmed their decision to enter the competition.

The health spokesman officially launched his campaign at Clydebank today.

Following the Supreme Court ruling that Holyrood could not legislate on a referendum without Westminster’s consent, Ms Sturgeon announced her intention to campaign for an independence majority in next year’s UK general election.

But Mr Yousaf insisted the policy will not necessarily remain in place.

“I have some concerns. I don’t agree with the idea of ​​using general elections as a de facto referendum,” he said.

“But I would say that we need to stop talking about process and start talking about politics because if independence becomes the will of the Scottish people then those political obstacles will go away.”

Ms Sturgeon’s resignation came ahead of a shock poll that suggested the SNP and Labor were almost neck and neck in support of a Westminster election (percentages).

Mr Yousaf said he could not pretend that the gender identity bill pushed by Ms Sturgeon had not “caused some division” within the SNP.

But he vowed to stick to the legislation and challenge the UK government’s decision to block it with a Section 35 order.

He said: “There is the principle of the injunction of Section 35 that I think we the Scottish Parliament must defend against.

Who is Humza Yousaf?

Humza Yousaf, 37, is the Scottish Government’s Health Minister who became Scotland’s first Muslim Cabinet Minister in 2018 when he was appointed Minister for Justice.

He has been MSP for Glasgow Pollok since 2016, having been elected to the Scottish Parliament as an Additional Member for the Glasgow region in 2011 aged just 26.

Although he has been proposed as a possible replacement for Ms Sturgeon as First Minister, Mr Yousaf’s chances could be hampered by the current health crisis in Scotland.

The long wait times for ambulances and emergency care have come under particular pressure.

Mr. Yousaf has a daughter and a stepchild with his second wife Nadia El-Nakla.

“But I think on this broader issue I would like to work with those who have real concerns. Let’s get in touch with them. Let’s try to bring them to the table. Let’s not let this issue define us as a movement.’

Mr Yousaf appears to be gaining support from many of Ms Sturgeon’s key allies amid an information campaign against Ms Forbes.

There are claims the Scottish Greens could pull out of their current power-sharing arrangement in Holyrood if Ms Forbes takes over.

The 32-year-old is a member of the Free Church of Scotland, sometimes known as the ‘Wee Frees’, which opposes gay marriage and believes there are few circumstances in which an abortion is justified.

SNP Deputy Leader Keith Brown, Environment Secretary Mairi McAllan and Culture Secretary Neil Gray all confirmed yesterday that they will not stand.

Ms Forbes has long been considered a potential successor to the First Minister.

She was thrust into the spotlight when she had to step in at the eleventh hour and deliver the Scottish household in 2020 after her predecessor Derek Mackay fell out of favor.

Candidates have until Friday to secure 100 nominations from at least 20 local branches to secure their spot on the ballot, with the new SNP leader being announced on March 27.

The post The three SNP hopefuls battling it out to take over from Nicola Sturgeon   appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.

By James Tapsfield, Political Editor at Mailonline

11:09 February 20, 2023, updated 15:50 February 20, 2023

• Race is to be succeeded by Nicola Sturgeon as head of the SNP and first minister
• Kate Forbes, who has long been talked about as a potential successor, announced today

The battle to succeed Nicola Sturgeon intensified today as Kate Forbes cut her maternity leave to throw her hat in the ring.

The Scottish Finance Minister, seen by many as a front-runner, has attacked the outgoing leader as she said the SNP needed a “broader” appeal and someone “fresh-faced”.

In a video shared on social media showing footage of the stunning Scottish countryside, a tartan-clad woman gave Forbes a nod to the apparently stalled Separatist campaign north of the border.

She warned that nationalists risked “being frustrated on the road to self-determination” and said she had the “vision, experience and competence to inspire voters across Scotland”.

“We urgently need to unleash the full talent of the SNP, the broader yes movement and the country as a whole,” she said.

Ms Forbes was hot-tipped despite concerns her ties to an anti-gay marriage and anti-abortion evangelical church could be harmful.

Constitutional Secretary Angus Robertson confirmed this morning that he will not run for the party’s top post.

Scottish Finance Minister Kate Forbes lamented the need to “broaden” the SNP’s appeal as she confirmed she is a candidate in a slick video by Kate Forbes Nicola Sturgeon

Ms Sturgeon dropped the bombshell she was dropping last week after a heated spell that saw the SNP thrown into chaos over its failed attempt to relax gender identity rules and dwindling support for independence.

Visiting the Roslin Institute in Midlothian today, minutes before Ms Forbes’ statement, she expressed “tremendous confidence that the SNP will select someone with ability”.

“It’s clear that there’s a spectrum of talent on display there.”

Appearing in the video against a backdrop of the Scottish countryside and with a tartan scarf around her neck, Ms Forbes said: “Friends in the SNP, our nation and our movement are at an important crossroads. The decisions we make over the next few weeks will have a profound impact on our future and the future of our children.

“I cannot sit back and watch as our nation is thwarted on the road to self-determination. Our small independent neighbors are enjoying more prosperous, fairer and greener societies, and so should we.

“We urgently need to unleash the full talent of the SNP, the broader yes movement and the country as a whole.

Who is the contender for the SNP leadership, Kate Forbes?

Kate Forbes is a senior member of Ms Sturgeon’s administration, who is being tipped as the favorite to replace her.

The fluent Gaelic speaker became Finance Minister in the Scottish Government in February 2020, the first woman to hold the post.

Kate Forbes married Alasdair MacLennan – a widowed chimney sweep ten years her senior – in July 2021.

Their wedding was streamed online because Covid restrictions limited the number of people who could attend.

The 32-year-old went on maternity leave last July – becoming the first acting Scottish Cabinet Secretary ever – and gave birth to their daughter Naomi in August.

It was previously believed that Ms Forbes harbored no leadership ambitions, although she has been touted as a future SNP leader since entering the Scottish Parliament as MSP for Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch in 2016.

The daughter of missionaries, Mrs. Forbes spent much of her childhood in India.

She is a member of the Free Church of Scotland, sometimes known as the ‘Wee Frees’, which opposes gay marriage and believes there are few circumstances in which an abortion is justified.

Ms Forbes has previously said she was “guilty” of “tiptoeing around” her Christian faith in interviews.

Ms Sturgeon’s government has been accused of rushing through its controversial gender identity reforms ahead of Christmas while Ms Forbes stayed on maternity leave to prevent a possible revolt by the 32-year-old.

“We must elect strong, competent leadership to ensure independence, the leadership that I can offer.

“I think we need someone who can unite our party and our movement. I am a unifier, I will reach out and listen to make each member feel valued and empowered to contribute.

“This is also important if we want to convince others of the merits of independence. But now we also need someone who has our economy and our finances under control.

“In the midst of a cost of living crisis and the need to plan for independence, my years of managing the household and economy of Scotland have given me the experience we need to do just that.

“More than anything, we need a leader who is bold, courageous and energetic, with fresh faces and ready for new challenges.

“Someone who will inspire your confidence as an SNP member and inspire the people of Scotland to vote for a better future

“I am that leader and I want to lead our party to better days with integrity and commitment for the sake of your children and mine.”

Health Minister Humza Yousaf and former community security minister Ash Regan clashed over three major policy issues – independence, gender reform and road building – yesterday as they confirmed their decision to enter the competition.

Mr Yousaf also appeared to enlist the support of many of Ms Sturgeon’s key allies while an information campaign was launched against Ms Forbes.

There are claims the Scottish Greens could pull out of their current power-sharing arrangement in Holyrood if Ms Forbes takes over.

The 32-year-old is a member of the Free Church of Scotland, sometimes known as the ‘Wee Frees’, which opposes gay marriage and believes there are few circumstances in which an abortion is justified.

SNP Deputy Leader Keith Brown, Environment Secretary Mairi McAllan and Culture Secretary Neil Gray all confirmed yesterday that they would not run.

As the dispute escalated, former Health Secretary Jeane Freeman urged those who informed each other to stop fighting or risk losing support.

Business Secretary Ivan McKee said an announcement from the “enormously talented” Ms Forbes could be expected later.

He told BBC Radio Scotland’s Good Morning Scotland program: “Kate has some big decisions to make, of course this happened during her maternity leave, she had no intention of returning until early April and as we all know the announcements last week were for everyone a surprise.

“So Kate has had to assess her position and understand what can be done, but I understand she has considered that and will make an announcement later today and we’ll see what she has to say.”

Mr McKee said he would support Ms Forbes if she decided to run.

He said: “I think Kate is an extremely talented person. I have had the pleasure of working with her over the past seven years and seeing first hand what she can achieve, her focus on what matters to Scotland and her ability to connect with people in Scotland on a very real and authentic level to get in touch and convince them of their case.

Scottish Health Secretary Humza Yousaf is running for the SNP’s top post

‘And I think these talents to deliver excellent public services, a strong economy, a green economy for Scotland and to convince people of the SNP and independence are exactly the assets we need in a leader.’

Ms Forbes has long been considered a potential successor to the First Minister.

She was thrust into the spotlight when she had to step in at the eleventh hour and deliver the Scottish household in 2020 after her predecessor Derek Mackay fell out of favor.

Candidates have until Friday to secure 100 nominations from at least 20 local branches to secure their spot on the ballot, with the new SNP leader being announced on March 27.

The post Who’s Kate Forbes? Meet the SNP management hopeful backed to succeed Nicola Sturgeon appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.

Von James Tapsfield, politischer Redakteur bei Mailonline

13:10 21. Februar 2023, aktualisiert 17:57 21. Februar 2023

Die SNP befindet sich heute Abend in einer Kernschmelze, nachdem Kate Forbes, Spitzenreiterin der Führung, trotzig ihre frommen christlichen Ansichten zu Themen von der Homo-Ehe bis zur Geschlechtsidentität zur Schau gestellt hat.

Die schottische Finanzministerin bestand darauf, dass Sex vor der Ehe und uneheliche Kinder „falsch“ seien in einem außergewöhnlichen 24-Stunden-Gemetzel, das ihre Bewerbung um die Nachfolge von Nicola Sturgeon anscheinend im Stich gelassen hat.

Die Verbündeten geben zu, dass Frau Forbes es „vermasselt“ hat, wobei SNP-Aktivisten als die sozial liberalsten gelten.

Frau Forbes, ein Mitglied der Free Church of Scotland, könnte sogar mit einer internen SNP-Disziplinaruntersuchung konfrontiert werden, nachdem sie ITV Border gesagt hat: „Ich glaube, dass eine Transfrau ein biologischer Mann ist, der sich als Frau identifiziert.“

Die Parteiregeln legen nahe, dass die Bezeichnung von Transfrauen als „biologische Männer“ als transphob eingestuft werden kann.

Die 32-Jährige, die ihren Mutterschaftsurlaub verkürzte, um an dem Wettbewerb teilzunehmen, zuckte jedoch die Kehrtwendungen einer Reihe zuvor unterstützender MSPs ab.

Sie bestand darauf, dass sie nicht die Absicht habe, ihre Ansichten anderen „aufzuzwingen“, und dass es „illiberal“ sei, Menschen mit „ziemlich Mainstream“-religiösen Ansichten als „jenseits“ zu behandeln.

Die MSP schien heute Nachmittag anzuerkennen, dass ihre Ambitionen vereitelt werden könnten, und sagte, ihre Kampagne werde „im Moment“ fortgesetzt.

Inmitten einer Reihe von Angriffen im Laufe des Tages forderte die SNP-Abgeordnete Joanna Cherry, die mit den religiösen Ansichten von Frau Forbes nicht einverstanden ist, hochrangige Persönlichkeiten auf, „die Hunde abzurufen“, und sagte, der „Fressrausch sei ungehörig und schlecht für die Partei“.

Das bröckelnde Führungsangebot lässt Gesundheitsministerin Humza Yousaf als Favoritin für die Übernahme von Frau Sturgeon zurück – hat aber auch die massive Kluft im Herzen der Partei hervorgehoben.

Die Kandidatin der SNP-Führung, Kate Forbes (heute abgebildet), sagte, sie hätte gegen die Homo-Ehe in Schottland gestimmt, als sie vor fast einem Jahrzehnt legalisiert wurde. Die Kernschmelze lässt Gesundheitsministerin Humza Yousaf als Favoritin zurück, die Frau Sturgeon Nicola Sturgeon (im Bild) übernimmt bei einem Besuch in Midlothian gestern) ließ die Bombe platzen, die sie letzte Woche aufgibt, nach einer heißen Phase, in der die SNP wegen ihres fehlgeschlagenen Versuchs, die Regeln zur Geschlechtsidentität zu lockern, und ihrer schwindenden Unterstützung für Unabhängigkeit ins Chaos geriet

Frau Forbes sah bereits in Schwierigkeiten aus, nachdem sie über Nacht zugegeben hatte, dass sie gegen die Homo-Ehe gestimmt hätte.

Und heute Nachmittag sagte sie Sky News, dass es „etwas ist, das ich vermeiden würde“, außereheliche Kinder zu haben.

„In Bezug auf meinen Glauben würde mein Glaube sagen, dass Kinder – er sagt, dass Sex für die Ehe ist. Das ist der Ansatz, den ich praktizieren würde “, sagte sie.

Frau Forbes bestand darauf, dass es kein Thema sei, über das sie „aufgeregt“ sei, und schlug vor, dass sie „meine Ansichten anderen Menschen nicht aufzwingen“ würde, und sie „akzeptiere“ Familie und Freunde, die diese „Entscheidungen“ getroffen haben.

Aber auf die Frage, ob es falsch sei, außereheliche Kinder zu haben, antwortete sie: „Für mich wäre es nach meinem Glauben falsch.“

Frau Forbes sagte: „In einer liberalen Gesellschaft können Sie koexistieren und diese Debatten und Diskussionen führen“, sagte sie. „Ich denke, es hat eine faszinierende Frage im Herzen des schottischen politischen Diskurses ans Licht gebracht, nämlich: Was bedeutet Liberalismus?

„Sind wir so illiberal geworden, dass wir diese Diskussionen nicht führen können, oder sind einige Leute über den Rand gestolpert? Denn wenn einige Leute über das Blasse hinaus sind, dann sind dies dunkle und gefährliche Tage für Schottland.

“Ich denke, diese Kampagne wird das hervorheben.”

Die SNP-Politikerin sah sich zunächst einer Gegenreaktion gegenüber, nachdem sie darauf bestanden hatte, dass sie die Ehe als zwischen einem Mann und einer Frau betrachtet.

Sie sagte, sie hätte gegen die gleichgeschlechtliche Ehe gestimmt, wenn sie damals MSP gewesen wäre, betonte jedoch, dass sie die Rechte der Menschen nach geltendem Recht verteidigen werde.

Frau Forbes sprach heute Morgen im Times Radio und versuchte, die Folgen zu glätten.

„Ich bereue den Schmerz oder die Verletzung, die mir zugefügt wurde, sehr, denn das war auch nicht meine Absicht, und ich würde um Vergebung bitten, wenn es so rüberkommt“, sagte sie.

Frau Forbes fügte hinzu, dass sie die Rechte von LGBT+-Personen verteidige, „frei von Belästigung, Angst und Vorurteilen“ zu leben.

Sie verglich ihre Haltung mit der von Angela Merkel, die einer Abstimmung über das Thema zustimmte, sich gegen die Änderung aussprach, dann aber den Willen des Deutschen Bundestages umsetzte.

Lesen Sie mehr: Wie der rücksichtslose Ehrgeiz des scheidenden Führers Schottland vor einer Reihe von Skandalen an den Rand der Unabhängigkeit brachte

„Meine Position in diesen Angelegenheiten ist, dass ich das Recht aller in einer pluralistischen und toleranten Gesellschaft, frei von Belästigung und Angst zu leben und zu lieben, nach Kräften verteidigen werde“, sagte sie.

„Und auf die gleiche Weise hoffe ich, dass anderen das Recht von Menschen des Glaubens gewährt werden kann, einen fairen Mainstream-Unterricht zu praktizieren. Und das ist die Nuance, die wir bei der gleichberechtigten Ehe einfangen müssen.“

Herausgefordert, dass ihre Kampagne so gut wie beendet war, sagte Frau Forbes: „Absolut nicht. Wir haben eine große Parteimitgliedschaft, von denen die meisten nicht auf Twitter sind.

„Ich verstehe, dass die Leute sehr starke Ansichten zu diesen Angelegenheiten haben. Ich denke, die Öffentlichkeit sehnt sich danach, dass Politiker klare Fragen mit klaren Antworten beantworten, und das habe ich gestern in den Medien versucht. Das lässt nicht unbedingt viele Nuancen zu.

“Meine Position in diesen Angelegenheiten ist, dass ich in einer pluralistischen und toleranten Gesellschaft die Rechte aller Menschen, frei von Belästigung und Angst zu leben und zu lieben, mit Nachdruck verteidigen werde.”

Die gleichberechtigte Ehe wurde 2014 in Schottland mit einer überwältigenden Mehrheit von 105 zu 18 Stimmen legalisiert, während Frau Forbes erst bei den Wahlen 2016 in Holyrood gewählt wurde.

Frau Forbes sagte zuvor, sie hätte nicht für das Gesetz zur Reform der Geschlechtsanerkennung (Schottland) der schottischen Regierung in seiner jetzigen Form gestimmt.

Da sie sich in Elternzeit befand, nahm sie vor dem neuen Jahr nicht an der Schlussabstimmung teil, ist aber seit 2019 klar dagegen.

Sie war eine von 15 SNP-Politikern, die ihre Partei öffentlich aufforderten, die umstrittenen Vorschläge zu verschieben, die es Transgender-Personen erleichtern, sich selbst als ihr gewähltes Geschlecht zu identifizieren.

Sie sagte: „Meine Bedenken hinsichtlich der Selbstidentifikation waren gut dokumentiert, und ich hätte diese Bedenken hinsichtlich der Selbstidentifikation weiterhin gehabt.

„Es ist sehr schwierig, hypothetisch zu sprechen, wenn es um einen Gesetzentwurf geht, aber ich glaube, ich hätte Mühe gehabt, dieses Selbstidentifizierungselement des Gesetzes zur Anerkennung des Geschlechts zu unterstützen.“

Hätte sie dagegen gestimmt, hätte sie ihre Position als Finanzministerin aufgeben müssen.

In einer weiteren umstrittenen Intervention sagte Frau Forbes, der verurteilte Transgender-Vergewaltiger, der ursprünglich in ein Frauengefängnis gebracht wurde, sei „ein Mann“.

Frau Sturgeon wich zuvor Fragen aus, ob Isla Bryson, früher bekannt als Adam Graham, eine Frau ist, nachdem die 31-Jährige zweier sexueller Angriffe für schuldig befunden worden war.

Aber im Gespräch mit dem Daily Telegraph sagte Frau Forbes unmissverständlich, dass „kein Vergewaltiger eine Frau sein kann“ und dass „Isla Bryson ein Mann ist“.

Frau Forbes beschuldigte ihre Gegner auch, sie wegen ihres christlichen Glaubens angegriffen zu haben, „und nicht wegen ihrer Kompetenz, Erfahrung oder Vision“.

Sie sagte: „Wir müssen sehr vorsichtig sein, dass wir in Schottland nicht sagen, dass Sie kein öffentliches Amt bekleiden können, selbst das höchste öffentliche Amt, wenn Sie Mitglied eines bestimmten Glaubens sind.

„Oder Sie können ein öffentliches Amt bekleiden, aber Sie müssen tatsächlich Ihren Glauben abstreifen. Das scheint mir ein sehr illiberaler Ansatz zu sein.

Sie fügte hinzu: „Mein Ansatz ist, dass ich offen mit dem Glauben umgegangen bin, dem Einfluss des Glaubens auf mein Leben.

“Aber wir scheinen in der Lage zu sein, einen Hindu in Nummer 10 zu haben, ist es übertrieben zu glauben, dass wir einen Christen in Bute House haben könnten?”

“Ich würde viel lieber mit der britischen Regierung über die Änderungen diskutieren, die vorgenommen werden müssen, als mit der Herausforderung fortzufahren.”

Isla Bryson – früher bekannt als Andrew Graham – wurde im Januar vor Gericht in Glasgow abgebildet

Wer ist Humza Yousaf?

Humza Yousaf, 37, ist der Gesundheitsminister der schottischen Regierung, der 2018 Schottlands erster muslimischer Kabinettsminister wurde, als er zum Justizminister ernannt wurde.

Er ist seit 2016 MSP für Glasgow Pollok, nachdem er bereits 2011 im Alter von nur 26 Jahren als zusätzliches Mitglied für die Region Glasgow in das schottische Parlament gewählt worden war.

Obwohl er als möglicher Ersatz für Frau Sturgeon als Erste Ministerin vorgeschlagen wurde, könnten die Chancen von Herrn Yousaf durch die aktuelle Gesundheitskrise in Schottland beeinträchtigt werden.

Besonders unter Druck geraten sind die langen Wartezeiten auf Krankenwagen und Notfallversorgung.

Herr Yousaf hat mit seiner zweiten Frau Nadia El-Nakla eine Tochter und ein Stiefkind.

Im Gespräch mit The Scotsman sagte Frau Forbes, die sich seit Frühsommer letzten Jahres im Mutterschaftsurlaub und von der Frontpolitik ferngehalten hat, dass sie die gleichberechtigte Ehe nicht als „Gewissenssache“ unterstützt hätte, wenn sie Abgeordnete im Parlament gewesen wäre Zeit.

Sie führte das Beispiel von Angela Merkel als einer Führungspersönlichkeit an, die über die Angelegenheit „mit ihrem Gewissen“ abgestimmt habe.

Sie sagte: „Ich hätte aus Gewissensgründen für die Lehre der meisten großen Religionen gestimmt, dass die Ehe zwischen Mann und Frau besteht.

„Aber ich hätte die getroffene demokratische Entscheidung respektiert und verteidigt.

“Es ist jetzt ein legales Recht und ich bin ein Diener der Demokratie, ich bin kein Diktator.”

Frau Forbes verurteilte auch den „illiberalen Diskurs“ um ihren Glauben und wie ihre religiösen Ansichten ihre Entscheidungen als Erste Ministerin beeinflussen könnten.

Sie ist Mitglied der Free Church of Scotland und hatte zuvor gesagt, ihr Glaube habe keinen Einfluss auf ihre Fähigkeit, als MSP zu dienen.

Herr Yousaf sagte, er werde „immer für die Gleichberechtigung anderer kämpfen“.

Auf die Frage, was er davon halte, was Frau Forbes zur gleichgeschlechtlichen Ehe zu sagen habe, sagte Herr Yousaf gegenüber der Sendung Good Morning Scotland von BBC Radio Scotland: „Es ist ihre Sache, ihre Ansichten zu verteidigen, ich habe meine Ansichten sehr klar zum Ausdruck gebracht.

„Ich denke, meine Erfolgsbilanz in Gleichstellungsfragen spricht eine klare und deutliche Sprache.

„Ich bin eine Minderheit in diesem Land, ich war mein ganzes Leben lang eine Minderheit, und meine Rechte existieren nicht in einem Vakuum, meine Rechte hängen von den Rechten anderer Menschen ab, und deshalb glaube ich sehr fest daran, und zwar mit jeder Faser mein Wesen, dass deine Gleichheit meine Gleichheit ist, deshalb werde ich immer für die Gleichberechtigung anderer kämpfen, egal wer sie sind.’

Die schottische Finanzministerin Kate Forbes kritisierte die Notwendigkeit, die Attraktivität der SNP zu „erweitern“, als sie bestätigte, dass sie kandidiert

Wer ist die Anwärterin auf die SNP-Führung, Kate Forbes?

Kate Forbes ist ein führendes Mitglied der Verwaltung von Frau Sturgeon, die als Favoritin für ihren Ersatz gehandelt wird.

Die fließend Gälisch sprechende Sprecherin wurde im Februar 2020 Finanzministerin der schottischen Regierung, die erste Frau in diesem Amt.

Kate Forbes heiratete im Juli 2021 Alasdair MacLennan – einen verwitweten Schornsteinfeger, der zehn Jahre älter war als sie.

Ihr Ehemann, bekannt als Ali, hatte drei Töchter – Rachael, Rebekah und Zara – mit seiner indischen ersten Frau Priya. Sie starb 2014 im Alter von nur 38 Jahren.

Frau Forbes, 32, ging im vergangenen Juli in den Mutterschaftsurlaub – die erste amtierende schottische Kabinettssekretärin überhaupt – und brachte im August ihre Tochter Naomi zur Welt.

Als Tochter von Missionaren verbrachte Frau Forbes einen Großteil ihrer Kindheit in Indien.

Sie ist Mitglied der Free Church of Scotland, manchmal auch als „Wee Frees“ bekannt, die gegen die Homo-Ehe ist und glaubt, dass es nur wenige Umstände gibt, unter denen eine Abtreibung gerechtfertigt ist.

Die Regierung von Frau Sturgeon wurde beschuldigt, ihre umstrittenen Reformen zur Geschlechtsidentität vor Weihnachten durchgezogen zu haben, während Frau Forbes im Mutterschaftsurlaub blieb, um eine mögliche Revolte der 32-Jährigen zu verhindern.

The post Now SNP hopeful Kate Forbes says having intercourse outdoors marriage is ‘incorrect’ appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.