San Francisco regulators have pushed back a vote to lift San Francisco’s ban on city officials doing business with companies headquartered in states that have enacted anti-LGBTQ laws, abortion bans or restricted voting access in recent years. They did so despite objections from local minorities and LGBTQ entrepreneurs who fear it will have a negative impact on them.

Meanwhile, District 8 gay warden Rafael Mandelman on Tuesday introduced an ordinance to completely abandon the city’s policy of banning travel to and doing business in conservative states. He was joined as co-sponsors by Supervisors Catherine Stefani of District 2 and Hilary Ronen of District 9, and Board Chairperson Aaron Peskin, representing District 3.

“Removing 12X will increase bidding competition and reduce contract costs, saving San Francisco tens of millions or more each year. And it will better advance our social policy goals by allowing us to engage with the actual communities impacted by restrictive LGBTQ, abortion, voting and human rights policies,” Mandelman said in announcing the regulation. “I got it As I said before, the best pressure we can put on red states is to show that progressive San Francisco can be governed effectively.”

District 11 Supervisor Ahsha Safaí had requested that the vote on his ordinance be postponed to the March 14 Board of Supervisors meeting to continue meeting with business leaders in the city. Last November, he introduced the ordinance to abolish the contracting ban.

But when the Regulators’ Rules Committee, of which Safaí is a part, finally raised the city policy overhaul known as 12X at its February 13 meeting, local business leaders complained that they had not been consulted on the matter. Safaí promised to meet with them to hear their concerns and asked for the continuation at Tuesday’s full board meeting to continue those discussions.

“We’ve had some of those talks, but I want to give space to continue those talks,” said Safaí, who voted to introduce the 12X policy when it was first proposed.

The 11 supervisors voted unanimously to allow progress, although District 7 Supervisor Myrna Melgar suggested that more time was needed to gather community input on the 12X policy change. It also includes a ban on most taxpayer-funded city breaks in the 30 states now covered by the directive, although the travel ban would not be affected by Safaí’s regulation.

“If we’re going to reform it, we have to do it wisely,” Melgar said, adding that she feared two weeks wasn’t “enough time to get the community involved.”

District 10 Supervisor Shamann Walton reiterated his opposition to the proposal, which he originally made during the hearing before the Rules Committee, of which he is vice chair. A major objection made by Walton is that changing the 12X policy would result in rewards for large multinational corporations headquartered in states that have legislated against the values ​​that support San Francisco and its residents.

“In my opinion, this will only support the people who support these discriminatory laws,” Walton said.

The 12X Directive was first enacted in 2016 and initially included only those states that had previously passed laws that discriminated against their LGBTQ residents. In 2019, the policy was extended to states that restricted abortion and again in 2021 to states with election-busting laws. California also has a law that bans most taxpayer-funded travel to states that have passed anti-LGBTQ laws in the past eight years, but does not prohibit contracts with companies in those states.

With more than half the country now on San Francisco’s blacklist, critics argue it’s hampering city governments’ ability to find qualified contractors. They also insist it increases the cost of projects because companies that could make the work less expensive won’t bid for them at all if they’re in a banned state.

Critics of 12X, like District 6 gay supervisor Matt Dorsey, also claim that it has failed in its goal of convincing lawmakers in affected states to repeal the laws that put them on San Francisco’s ban list . According to a 16-page memo the city government’s office sent to regulators earlier this month, the implications of the 12X policy in other states are “not clear.”

It concluded that the 12X policy created “additional administrative burdens for city staff and vendors and unintended consequences for San Francisco citizens, such as: B. the restriction of enrichment and development opportunities”.

The memo came at the request of five supervisors who asked the city bureau to review the 12X policy last October. Among them was Mandelman, who supports updating the ban but had been working on his own ordinance for it.

“I don’t think the right way to make a change is to flip the bird and walk away,” he told the Bay Area Reporter, writing last week that supervisors are slowing down their decision-making process on the 12X should policy.

In a letter sent to the Rules Committee and shared with all supervisors, the San Francisco Latino Black Builders Association questioned whether there was any data showing that a change to the 12X policy was warranted. It asked supervisors to require city authorities to prove that work efficiency was reduced or costs increased as a result of the contract ban.

“We support the intent of the original regulation and the support it offers to LGBTQ communities across the country. We also approve of the idea of ​​supporting local and Californian businesses,” wrote Anne Cervantes, a founder and co-chair of the association.

But former District 8 gay supervisor Scott Wiener, now a senator, is urging current supervisors to repeal the entire 12X policy he originally wrote. It is no longer a sound public policy, he claims.

“When I penned 12X, we believed that a coalition of cities and states would form to create real consequences for states that enact these despicable, hateful laws,” Wiener said. “However, as it turns out, that coalition never formed and the full potential impact of those policies never materialized. Instead, San Francisco is now penalizing businesses in other states — including LGBTQ owners, women owners, and people of color. owned corporations — for the sins of their far-right governments. Additionally, the City of San Francisco employees are unable to fly to a large number of states for critical needs, whether collaborating on HIV prevention and treatment strategies or helping working together on critical transportation strategies, it is time to acknowledge that this policy has not worked and we must back down.”

UPDATED 2/28/23 to include the new regulation put in place to repeal the entire 12X policy.

Help keep the Bay Area Reporter going during these trying times. To support local, independent LGBTQ journalism, consider becoming a BAR member.

The post UPDATED: San Francisco supervisors transfer to finish journey and contract bans masking conservative states :: Bay Space Reporter appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.

PIX nowHere’s the latest from the KPIX newsroom. (3-21-21)

21 minutes ago

Asian American Attacks: Andrea Nakano of KPIX 5 on the challenges of growing up races in the Bay Area and JapanAndrea Nakano of KPIX 5 on the challenges of growing up breeds in the Bay Area and Japan

57 minutes ago

Asians on the attack: the Bay Area reactsKenny Choi and Elizabeth Cook host a KPIX special report on the worrying rise in racial intimidation and violence against the Asian-American and Pacific islander communities in the Bay Area and across the country. (3-21-21)

58 minutes ago

Asian American Attacks: KPIX 5’s Sharon Chin explains how difficult it is to see the pictures of the elderly victims of the attacksThe Sharon Chin family at KPIX 5 has been based in California since the 1850s. She has older relatives and struggles with the images of older victims of hate crimes.

58 minutes ago

Asian American Attacks: KPIX 5 reporter Kiet Do recalls being labeled a racial fraud in a car accidentAt the beginning of KPIX reporter’s career, Kiet Do, he covered a car accident in Georgia when an accident victim labeled him a racial fraud

1 hour ago

Asian American Attacks: A Guide for Parents Having Difficulty Explaining Hate Crimes to ChildrenThe ongoing nationwide attacks on the AAPI community are forcing Asian American parents to enter into tense, complex discussions about race and racism in their immediate families. Kiet Do reports. (3-21-21)

1 hour ago

Asian-American Attacks: Social media surveillance videos silence doubts about Asian-American attacksAsia-American leaders say the recent unprovoked attacks, which were taped, have forced people to act and speak up.

1 hour ago

Asian-American Attacks: KPIX’s Mary Lee reflects her family’s long legacy in the Bay AreaKPIX’s Mary Lee reflects her family’s long legacy in the Bay Area

1 hour ago

Asians on the attack: Investigators work to determine if Atlanta Spa killings were hate crimesOutrage over those who believe that investigators overseeing the mass shooting case in Georgia should accuse the suspect of a hate crime has swept across the country. Maria Medina reports. (3-21-21)

2 hours ago

Asian American Attacks: Attacks on Asian Americans on the rise in the Bay AreaSince the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, there has been a staggering increase in attacks against Asian Americans in the Bay Area

2 hours ago

The Church of San Francisco offers congregants single-shot COVID-19 vaccinationsOn Sunday, a San Francisco church began distributing Johnson & Johnson’s new COVID-19 vaccine. By helping a color community, she also gives hope to the rest of the state. John Ramos reports. (3-21-21)

2 hours ago

Hundreds gather for the anti-hate rally in San JoseMore than a thousand protesters gathered outside San Jose City Hall on Sunday to condemn anti-Asian racism and violence. As Lin reports. (3-21-21)

2 hours ago

Stanford coach VanDerveer accuses NCAA of sexismStanford’s trainer Tara VanDerveer made an angry NCAA statement Saturday night about “evidence of overt sexism” that is “targeted and hurtful”. Jericka Duncan reports. (3-21-21)

2 hours ago

The San Francisco rally brings diverse communities together to condemn Asian hatredPeople of different racial backgrounds and ages showed up at Harvey Milk Plaza in the Castro District on Sunday to denounce the nationwide attacks on Asian Americans. Betty Yu reports. (3-21-21)

3 hours ago

Precise forecast for Sunday eveningSpring is here! (And not just because Juliette Goodrich’s pet turtle says so) Meteorologist Darren Peck has the 7-day forecast. (3-21-21)

3 hours ago

TODAY FORECAST: The latest forecast from the KPIX 5 weather teamThe latest forecast from the KPIX 5 weather team

13 hours ago

PIX nowSunday morning headlines from the KPIX 5 newsroom

13 hours ago

COVID: Emperor and Santa Clara County officials fight over second vaccine dosesOfficials from the Emperor and Santa Clara County fight over second doses of vaccine

14 hours ago

TONIGHT’S FORECAST: The latest forecast from the KPIX 5 weather teamSunny, warm weather for the first week of spring

23 hours ago

San Francisco School Board: Officials urge Alison Collins, vice president of the SF School Board, to resignSan Francisco’s top elected officials, including the mayor, lawmakers, and almost all regulators, called for the school board’s vice president, Alison Collins, to step down.

23 hours ago

PIX nowHere’s the latest from the KPIX newsroom. (3-20-21)

1 day ago

Hundreds of rallies in San Francisco to denounce violence against Asian AmericansA large rally was held in the heart of San Francisco’s Chinatown Saturday to show solidarity with the city’s Asian residents. John Ramos reports. (3-20-21)

1 day ago

Precise forecast on Saturday eveningMeteorologist Darren Peck on the outlook for precipitation in the next week. (3-20-21)

1 day ago

TODAY FORECAST: The latest forecast from our KPIX weather teamWarming trend all next week with no rain in sight

2 days ago

The post KPIX 5 reporter Kiet Do recollects being known as a racial slur whereas protecting a automotive crash – CBS San Francisco appeared first on DAILY SAN FRANCISCO BAY NEWS.